From reproductive rights to local weather change to Massive Tech, The Impartial is on the bottom when the story is creating. Whether or not it is investigating the financials of Elon Musk’s pro-Trump PAC or producing our newest documentary, ‘The A Phrase’, which shines a lightweight on the American ladies combating for reproductive rights, we all know how vital it’s to parse out the info from the messaging.
At such a essential second in US historical past, we want reporters on the bottom. Your donation permits us to maintain sending journalists to talk to either side of the story.
The Impartial is trusted by People throughout the whole political spectrum. And in contrast to many different high quality information shops, we select to not lock People out of our reporting and evaluation with paywalls. We imagine high quality journalism needs to be accessible to everybody, paid for by those that can afford it.
Your help makes all of the distinction.
The acclaimed American documentary filmmaker Michael Moore has responded to a cryptic message left by Luigi Mangione, the alleged murderer of UnitedHealthcare’s CEO.
Mangione faces a second-degree homicide cost for the deadly capturing of Brian Thompson, 50, exterior a Manhattan lodge on 4 December.
When arrested in Pennsylvania on Monday, Mangione was present in possession of a 262-page manifesto outlining his intentions and referencing infamous figures resembling Unabomber Ted Kaczynski.
Within the doc, Mangione additionally briefly talked about Michael Moore and former New York Instances reporter Elisabeth Rosenthal, citing them as people who’ve “illuminated the corruption and greed” of the healthcare business.
Luigi Mangione (AP)
Moore, the filmmaker behind Bowling for Columbine and Fahrenheit 9/11, is finest identified for his essential documentaries on societal and political points. In 2007, he launched Sicko, a hard-hitting examination of the US healthcare system that contrasted it with free medical providers within the UK, France, Canada, and Cuba.
In a Substack submit revealed on 6 December—earlier than it emerged that Mangione had referenced him—Moore addressed the capturing and the cryptic inscriptions on the bullet casings.
“All we all know now could be that the bullet casings used within the killing of the CEO included the inscriptions, ‘Deny,’ ‘Defend,’ or ‘Depose’—which may imply all the things, or nothing,” the Oscar winner wrote.
“They may have simply as simply stated, ‘From my chilly useless arms,’ or ‘Make America Nice Once more,’ or ‘Half-Off Tuesdays at Applebee’s!’” he added, injecting his signature mix of cynicism and humour.
Watch Apple TV+ free for 7 days
New subscribers solely. £8.99/mo. after free trial. Plan auto-renews till cancelled
Moore used the submit to reiterate his critique of the US healthcare system, describing it as “ugly” and “heartless.”
“To assist show my level,” he continued, “please take a second to let me share with you this prolonged clip from my Oscar-nominated documentary, Sicko, in regards to the origin and historical past of our medical insurance business and the way it makes cash off of us.”
He additionally uploaded a section of the movie to YouTube, titled Deny, Defend, Depose.
Michael Moore at a screening of ‘Sicko’ (Getty Pictures)
UnitedHealthcare was internet hosting an buyers’ convention in Manhattan on the day of Thompson’s killing, the place the CEO was scheduled to current the corporate’s monetary efficiency.
New York Police Division Chief Detective Joe Kenny acknowledged that the suspect referenced visiting the convention venue in his pocket book, in response to CNN.
The 26-year-old suspect is at present being held in a Pennsylvania jail with out bond, awaiting extradition to New York to face a homicide cost. He additionally faces extra prices for firearms violations in Pennsylvania.
From reproductive rights to local weather change to Massive Tech, The Impartial is on the bottom when the story is growing. Whether or not it is investigating the financials of Elon Musk’s pro-Trump PAC or producing our newest documentary, ‘The A Phrase’, which shines a light-weight on the American ladies preventing for reproductive rights, we all know how essential it’s to parse out the information from the messaging.
At such a vital second in US historical past, we’d like reporters on the bottom. Your donation permits us to maintain sending journalists to talk to each side of the story.
The Impartial is trusted by Individuals throughout your entire political spectrum. And in contrast to many different high quality information shops, we select to not lock Individuals out of our reporting and evaluation with paywalls. We imagine high quality journalism must be out there to everybody, paid for by those that can afford it.
Your assist makes all of the distinction.
After struggling a number of fractures when he crashed into certainly one of their automobiles, two-time Olympic champion Remco Evenepoel is teaming up with the Belgian Publish Workplace to boost consciousness of highway security for cyclists and cut back the variety of “dooring” victims.
“Dooring” is an accident the place the occupant of a parked automobile inadvertently opens the door into the trail of a bike owner approaching from behind.
Evenepoel crashed into the opened door of a Publish Workplace van on Dec. 3 with the impression heavy sufficient to interrupt the body of his bicycle. He additionally suffered torn ligaments, a dislocated collarbone and bruised lungs within the accident.
“All highway customers should take one another into consideration,” Evenepoel mentioned. The initiative ”will undoubtedly contribute to a greater consciousness of the risks on the highway. This can undoubtedly forestall many accidents.”
The brand new marketing campaign, known as “Remco Reflex,” was launched this week in partnership with Evenepoel’s biking academy. It goals to remind drivers to look over their shoulder earlier than opening their automobile door with a purpose to cut back the variety of accidents.
In line with the Belgian Publish Workplace, virtually 300 cyclists are injured yearly within the nation in dooring accidents.
The Remco Reflex marketing campaign incorporates a sticker bearing the picture of Evenepoel to be mounted to the automobile’s door window.
“Already skilled within the ‘Dutch Attain’ approach (opening the door with the alternative hand to raised examine for cyclists and, or pedestrians), drivers of submit automobiles could have one other everlasting reminder to be vigilant,” the Publish Workplace mentioned. “Bpost will due to this fact apply the ‘Remco Reflex’ in all its automobiles.”
The 24-year-old Evenepoel broke his proper shoulder blade, proper hand and a rib, his Soudal Fast-Step staff mentioned. He underwent profitable surgical procedure.
Evenepoel was the primary bike owner to brush the highway race and time trial at an Olympic Video games when he triumphed in each in Paris in August. A two-time world champion, Evenepoel additionally received the Spanish Vuelta in 2022 and completed third within the Tour de France this 12 months.
From reproductive rights to local weather change to Huge Tech, The Impartial is on the bottom when the story is growing. Whether or not it is investigating the financials of Elon Musk’s pro-Trump PAC or producing our newest documentary, ‘The A Phrase’, which shines a light-weight on the American girls preventing for reproductive rights, we all know how vital it’s to parse out the information from the messaging.
At such a vital second in US historical past, we’d like reporters on the bottom. Your donation permits us to maintain sending journalists to talk to each side of the story.
The Impartial is trusted by Individuals throughout your complete political spectrum. And in contrast to many different high quality information shops, we select to not lock Individuals out of our reporting and evaluation with paywalls. We consider high quality journalism ought to be out there to everybody, paid for by those that can afford it.
Your assist makes all of the distinction.
Rarely has the style of a person’s demise been so unbefitting of their life. On the night of 10 December 1964, soul sensation Sam Cooke dined with buddies at Martoni’s restaurant, the Los Angeles hangout of Hollywood A-listers and those who fed off them, flagrantly flashing across the $5,000 in money he’d produced from current tour dates. After a number of drinks, he started chatting with a younger lady on the bar. Later, he failed to point out up on the nightclub his buddies had gone to.
As a substitute, within the early hours of the following morning – 60 years in the past this week – Cooke was fatally shot by the supervisor of the Hacienda Motel, a hang-out of intercourse employees and pimps, amid accusations of kidnap and violence. His killing would finally be dismissed as “justifiable murder”.
Such a surprising dying, at simply 33, for a person thought of a delicate and high-class character by those that knew him finest, inevitably led to different theories. That Cooke was the sufferer of a honeytrap sting. That he’d been murdered by mobsters muscling in on his profitable SAR Information enterprise, or killed by his supervisor Allan Klein, whose shady dealings Cooke had not too long ago uncovered. Or that the FBI, having saved Cooke underneath surveillance as a consequence of his outstanding and highly effective place within the civil rights motion, had a hand in his premature dying.
Out of the murk, nevertheless, swiftly drifted away the true significance of Cooke’s life. Simply 11 days after his dying, the one “A Change Is Gonna Come” was launched, a closing showcase for one of many biggest soul voices of its era and a cry of hope and defiance from the sharp finish of American racism and segregation. “I’m going downtown, any person hold telling me ‘don’t hold round’,” Cooke sang over noble orchestration, “… however I do know a change ‘gon come.”
He might need been most well-known for frolicsome shake-shack tracks like “Twistin’ the Evening Away” and “Great World”, or heartfelt soul devotionals akin to “Convey It On House to Me” and “Cupid”, however “A Change Is Gonna Come” would develop into Cooke’s defining second, an empowering farewell message from a loud and high-profile champion of African-American emancipation; a tune that may assist rally and galvanise America’s Black group for the struggles – and victories – to return. Six a long time on, it nonetheless resonates right this moment.
“On the time, it wasn’t successful,” says Daniel Wolff, one of many authors of You Ship Me: The Life and Occasions of Sam Cooke. “It grew to become higher recognized after he died. The importance now, I can’t overstate. It’s not even a protest tune, that narrows it an excessive amount of.” Cooke wrote the tune in response to Bob Dylan’s hit protest tune “Blowin’ within the Wind”, however Wolff considers Cooke’s tune extra vital. “‘Blowin’ within the Wind’ isn’t emotional… it isn’t a soul tune in that it speaks to extra than simply your mind. ‘A Change Is Gonna Come’ does that.”
With so many questions surrounding his dying unanswered, it’s very important to Cooke’s many followers and champions that the occasions of his dying not overshadow his music and message. His voice, in spite of everything, would go on to affect Otis Redding, James Brown, Tina Turner and Stevie Surprise. His story, in the meantime, was one in every of righteous bravery within the face of discrimination, and an inspirational forerunner to the nice hip-hop enterprise empires of right this moment. Having sung along with his siblings on the Chicago church of his Baptist minister father from the age of six, Cooke’s crystalline, high-flying tones noticed him picked in his teenagers because the lead singer in gospel heartthrobs The Soul Stirrers, a form of god-fearing *Nsync who often turned church buildings into mini-Shea Stadiums.
“When Sam and the Soul Stirrers got here to [a] church, you’d’ve thought they had been gonna have a rock live performance there,” fellow Fifties singer Smokey Robinson recalled within the 2019 Netflix documentary ReMastered: The Two Killings of Sam Cooke. “There have been girls who had by no means even considered going to church till Sam and the Soul Stirrers had been there, and they’d be across the block 4 deep.”
Sam Cooke with gospel hearthrobs The Soul Stirrers, a form of god-fearing *Nsync (Michael Ochs Archives/Getty)
Cooke had the appears to be like of an angel and a voice to match. His vocals had been a sensation; a sweetly seductive trill that might burn with a ardour when actually fired up. “It had an attention-grabbing emotional vary,” says Wolff. “It could possibly be very mild within the pop stuff, romantic, after which it could possibly be harsh. Whenever you hear Reside on the Harlem Sq. Membership, 1963 [a recording unreleased until 1985], or “Convey It On House to Me”, there’s a gospel rasp that he had. And, in fact, he might do what they known as his yodel, that ululation on the high of his vary which was distinctive, his signature.”
Take pleasure in limitless entry to 100 million ad-free songs and podcasts with Amazon Music
Enroll now for a 4 month free trial (3 months for non-Prime members)
Quickly sufficient, the siren name of the satan’s music lured him in direction of the rock’n’roll rapids. “There was a possible in crossing over in pop music and rock’n’roll that wasn’t there in gospel,” says Wolff. “He’d form of reached the highest of gospel. Pop music supplied the chance to achieve a brand new viewers and discuss different issues.” (Cooke, although, didn’t hand over on faith. Later in life, amid his burgeoning friendship with Malcolm X, he grew to become more and more fascinated with Islam.)
Cooke was an prompt success within the pop sphere. His 1957 debut solo single “You Ship Me” launched him on to the highest of the US Billboard chart the place he’d stay a Prime 40 mainstay for the remainder of his life. The early Sixties noticed a few of his largest hits within the form of research corridor swoon tune “Great World” (“Don’t know a lot about historical past…”), Hallmark soul basic “Cupid” and “Twistin’ the Evening Away”, his infectious however calculated cash-in on the twist craze.
Cooke was an prompt success within the pop sphere along with his 1957 debut solo single hovering to the highest of the US Billboard chart (Netflix)
The second largest hit of his profession, although, was 1960’s grittier “Chain Gang”, a catchy quantity about exhausting labour that gave listeners an early trace of Cooke’s rising curiosity in political issues. The tune’s amenable dealing with of a contentious matter was proof of Cooke’s nous in interesting to each white and Black audiences concurrently. “He’s speaking about an virtually grotesque facet of American politics and race politics,” Wolff says, “however in a means that he can cross over with it, that individuals aren’t offended.”
Cooke’s rising fame in mainstream pop (his $100,000 RCA Victor deal in 1960 can be value $1m [£780,000] right this moment) made him a de facto pioneer of civil rights in well-liked tradition. It was a job he wholeheartedly embraced. When the KKK threatened to assault the theatre in Atlanta the place Cooke was making an look on the influential Dick Clark Present in 1958, Cooke stood his floor, doubtlessly placing his life on the road to carry out. Comparable stands and ideas powered a lot of his rise.
I’ve all the time detested individuals of any color, faith or nationality who lack braveness to face up and be counted
Sam Cooke on refusing to play to a segregated viewers in Memphis in 1960
He was the primary performer to put on his hair in its pure afro state, relatively than slicked again in imitation of the blue-eyed crooners. On one tour of the southern states, when police stopped his tour bus to arrest backing singer Dionne Warwick for being impolite to a white diner waitress, Cooke politely however firmly ejected them from the bus. And when booked to play to a segregated viewers in Memphis, he refused to play, even trying to muster a boycott of the present. “I’ve all the time detested individuals of any color, faith or nationality who lack braveness to face up and be counted,” he stated in 1960. “I hope by refusing to play to a segregated viewers it is going to assist to interrupt down racial segregation.”
Such attitudes made him a determine of defiance amongst America’s Black communities, even whereas he remained a butter-wouldn’t-melt teen idol to white audiences. “Whether or not it was teenage ladies who simply thought he was scrumptious, or teenage boys who thought ‘that is nice music’, it adjustments your perspective [on race],” Wolff argues. “When individuals let you know ‘these individuals’ aren’t vital, you go, wait, there’s Sam Cooke. He was vital. One thing’s mistaken with this formulation.”
Cooke’s activist leanings introduced him into the orbit of Muhammad Ali and Malcolm X, and thereby to the eye of the FBI, involved about their burgeoning energy and affect. In the meantime, he launched his personal SARS Information label and publishing firm in 1961 in an try and personal and management his music, a proto-Swiftian transfer that – alongside Berry Gordy’s Motown label – set a music empire blueprint for numerous rap moguls to return, but it surely additionally attracted mafia curiosity. Across the similar time, Cooke’s supervisor Allan Klein had finagled the corporate underneath his personal possession with out Cooke’s data. Whereas bedridden with sickness in December 1964 – and nonetheless heartbroken over the dying of his two-year-old son Vincent within the household pool in 1963 – Cooke uncovered Klein’s nefarious dealings amongst his paperwork and vowed to sack him the next week. Sadly, he wouldn’t survive the weekend.
The gospel crooner-turned-pop star pictured in ‘The Two Killings of Sam Cooke’ (Netflix)
Amid such a tangled net, the true occasions of Cooke’s dying won’t ever be recognized. The lady he met at Martoni’s and drunk-drove to the Hacienda Motel that night time was 22-year-old Elisa Boyer. Later to be arrested on prostitution expenses, she informed police that after they’d checked in as man and spouse she grew to become satisfied Cooke deliberate to rape her, so grabbed her garments (in addition to Cooke’s trousers containing the $5,000 in money) and fled, calling the police from a road telephone to report her kidnap. Sporting only a sports activities jacket, a livid Cooke was reported to have been shot by way of the center by motel proprietor Bertha Franklin in self-defence as he allegedly attacked her, satisfied she was shielding Boyer. His closing phrases: “Woman, you shot me.”
Family and friends of Cooke merely don’t recognise the violent and abusive character on the centre of this story. “He wasn’t that sort of particular person to assault any person,” his sister Agnes Cooke-Hoskins stated in 2005, “he was a lover.” His studio engineer Al Schmitt agreed. “He wasn’t that form of a man that needed to be domineering or have energy over individuals,” he informed the Netflix documentary. “I by no means noticed that in Sam.”
That this was a couple of Black man who didn’t know his place and to cease him he needed to be murdered
Boston Globe affiliate editor Renée Graham on the killing of Sam Cooke
Such dissonance has given rise to different theories. In keeping with The Boston Globe affiliate editor Renée Graham, his politics and recognition made Cooke a goal. “Elvis believed that there was a way within the music {industry} that Sam was getting too highly effective and needed to be stopped, which echoed what lots of people within the Black group thought,” she informed the documentary. “That this was a couple of Black man who didn’t know his place and to cease him he needed to be murdered.”
All makes an attempt at uncovering any extra data had been scuppered by the truth that the LAPD, initially unaware of who Cooke was, determined that his killing wasn’t value something however the scantest investigation. “The perspective was, ‘Oh properly, one other n***** obtained shot’,” Norman Edelen, one in every of few black LAPD officers on the time, informed Individuals in 2021.
Sam will get able to take {a photograph} within the early Nineteen Sixties (Getty)
Fortunately, within the a long time since his dying, Sam Cooke’s legacy has far transcended his ignominious passing. Wolff cites Cooke because the great-grandfather of right this moment’s industry-savvy aware rappers. “Sam Cooke is the precursor of politically conscious, musically astute performers, Black and white,” he says, pointing to the brand new Kendrick Lamar album as a direct descendent of Cooke’s efforts in increasing the thematic and stylistic prospects of African-American artists. “Sam all the time thought there was extra room and extra vary for a performer, particularly a Black performer, and Kendrick Lamar is among the individuals who’s the fulfilment of that promise. At its finest, [Cooke’s] was a imaginative and prescient of pop music that stated ‘individuals have to determine a approach to get alongside, this music may also help them do it’.”
His title has been showered with posthumous awards and accolades, from Corridor of Fame inductions to Lifetime Achievement Grammys. His songs have develop into a part of the bedrock of popular culture along with his heaven-scraping voice – the epitome of candy soul sonics –celebrated as among the many best that ever sang. To today, “A Change Is Gonna Come” is hailed as an anthem of the continuing battle for equality in America. “It was a very long time coming in 1964,” Graham stated, “and it’s the disgrace of this nation that that tune ought to nonetheless be so related.” The change is perhaps gradual in coming, however Sam Cooke’s immortal voice will perpetually be keen it on.
From reproductive rights to local weather change to Large Tech, The Unbiased is on the bottom when the story is growing. Whether or not it is investigating the financials of Elon Musk’s pro-Trump PAC or producing our newest documentary, ‘The A Phrase’, which shines a light-weight on the American ladies combating for reproductive rights, we all know how vital it’s to parse out the details from the messaging.
At such a crucial second in US historical past, we’d like reporters on the bottom. Your donation permits us to maintain sending journalists to talk to each side of the story.
The Unbiased is trusted by Individuals throughout the complete political spectrum. And in contrast to many different high quality information shops, we select to not lock Individuals out of our reporting and evaluation with paywalls. We imagine high quality journalism ought to be out there to everybody, paid for by those that can afford it.
Your assist makes all of the distinction.
Toto Wolff despatched a heartfelt message to Lewis Hamilton after the Brit’s remaining race for Mercedes, saying forward of his transfer to Ferrari: “If we will’t win, it’s best to win.”
Hamilton, who began sixteenth in his remaining race for the Silver Arrows in Abu Dhabi, surged by the sector and with a last-lap overtake on teammate George Russell, the 39-year-old completed simply outdoors the rostrum in fourth.
After 12 years and 6 world titles with Mercedes, Hamilton strikes to Ferrari in 2025, ending the best driver-team partnership in F1 historical past. Hamilton did some doughnuts on the house straight after the race.
Wolff informed Hamilton on the radio after the race: “Lewis that was the drive of a world champion, wonderful.
“If we will’t win [next year], then it’s best to win.”
In an emotional dialog between Hamilton, Wolff and race engineer Peter Bonnington, Hamilton stated: “That was enjoyable. We dreamed rather a lot however collectively we believed and achieved issues as a staff.
“Thanks for all of the braveness, the willpower and keenness for supporting me. It began out as a leap of religion and became a journey into the historical past books.
“I’m so grateful to everybody on the manufacturing unit. From the underside of my coronary heart all the most effective.
“I really like you guys, I actually actually do.”
Lewis Hamilton did some doughnuts after his remaining race for Mercedes (Getty Pictures)
Bonnington stated: “Stellar job, it’s been a pleasure all the best way.”
Hamilton completed the 2024 season in his worst-ever championship place – seventh – however did handle to interrupt his 31-month win duck at Silverstone in July.
Lando Norris received the season-ending race and in doing so guided McLaren to the 2024 constructors’ championship – their first staff title in 26 years.
The 2025 season begins with the Australian Grand Prix on 16 March.
King Charles and Princess Kate have grown shut through the years – and their bond might have been made even stronger by their mutual well being issues this yr.
In mid-June, because the pair each started to make public appearances once more after present process remedy, the royals made an look at Trooping the Color.
As is custom, the household gathered on the balcony at Buckingham Palace to wave to the crowds under – with the king breaking royal protocol to have Kate stand subsequent to him – the Mirror stories.
The earlier yr, the king has stood subsequent to his son, Kate’s husband Prince William.
Chatting with OK! Journal, former royal butler Grant Harrold stated: “It’s altering protocol to point out the King and Kate united with one another and going by way of comparable battles, so I might say that is all the way down to the King’s desire.
“The balcony [line-up] is orchestrated, so I’ve a sense the King stated to Kate, ‘You stand subsequent to me.’”
It’s thought the transfer might have been a mark of respect from the King in direction of the Princess, who had chosen his official birthday to return to the general public eye.
Throughout the occasion, Kate was seen whispering a remark to Charles, resulting in him laughing.
The pair have beforehand fondly expressed fondness and assist for one another.
In March, after Kate launched a video message confirming her prognosis to the world, Charles launch an announcement saying he was ‘so proud’ of her ‘for her braveness in talking as she did’.
He went on to explain her as his ‘beloved daughter-in-law’.
Charles is known to have made efforts to deliver Kate into the household fold early in her relationship along with his son, and he or she has been overheard calling the monarch ‘Grandpa’.
When Prince George, 11, Princess Charlotte, 9, and Louis, aged six, first arrived with their father William, they stopped on the kindness tree, exterior the abbey’s nice west door, and hung messages on its branches in recognition of somebody who has supported them throughout their lives.
#Louis #leaves #message #grandparents #kids #be a part of #Kate #carol #service
The Customary
#Louis #leaves #message #grandparents #kids #be a part of #Kate #carol #service
Kate is bravely easing again into royal duties following her most cancers analysis again in March and the tip of her remedy. She arrived in a surprising ensemble, sporting an attractive crimson coat with a classy outsized black bow.
Following the service, the royals shared photos of the household holding candles within the iconic abbey together with a message of hope for the world.
A submit on Kate and William’s shared X account, The Prince and Princess of Wales, learn: “A night to return collectively and rejoice this festive season because the Collectively at Christmas Carol Service returns to Westminster Abbey.
“Shining a light-weight on people from everywhere in the UK who’ve proven love, kindness and empathy in the direction of others of their communities.”
The 1,600 attendees had been invited in recognition of them having supported others indirectly.
The Waleses had been photographed arriving on the occasion on Friday night time, in a venue that may little doubt maintain a particular place of their coronary heart, having been the church the place William and Kate wed in 2011.
The younger royals additionally stopped at a “Kindness Tree” outdoors the Abbey’s nice west door and hung messages on its branches in dedication to somebody who supported them throughout their lives consistent with the theme of the night time, love and empathy.
They had been additionally launched to the Dean of Westminster, Dr David Hoyle once they first arrived with their father William.
In a touching second, Kate revealed that she had entrusted her youngest son Louis, six, to stay discreet concerning the efficiency by soloists from the Royal Ballet on the occasion.
Kate informed singer Paloma Religion, who carried out on the service tonight, that she had requested her youngest son Louis: “Can you retain a secret in any other case it received’t be a shock for Charlotte, who loves her ballet dancing.”
She stated that Louis agreed, explaining: “He has stored the key for, what, practically two weeks now.”
When Prince George, 11, Princess Charlotte, 9, and Louis, aged six, first arrived with their father William, they stopped on the kindness tree, outdoors the abbey’s nice west door, and hung messages on its branches in recognition of somebody who has supported them throughout their lives.
#Louis #leaves #message #grandparents #youngsters #be a part of #Kate #carol #service
The Customary
#Louis #leaves #message #grandparents #youngsters #be a part of #Kate #carol #service
