HomePod Mini vs. Amazon Echo vs. Nest Audio: Which smart speaker is best for 2020?

Fall 2020 is ready to see the launch of extra sensible audio system from main builders than ever earlier than, with one new Google Nest speaker already out, and now Apple’s new HomePod Mini and four new Amazon Echo devices on the way in which earlier than Thanksgiving. These units are core to every firm’s sensible residence ambitions, since a $100 voice-driven speaker — housing Siri, Alexa or Google Assistant — acts as probably the greatest anchors for a linked residence expertise.

We’re shifting into the primary vacation season affected by COVID-19 lockdowns, and persons are residence greater than ever proper now. Because of this, and with three aggressive sensible speaker manufacturers in the marketplace, 2020 may see an enormous growth on this nonetheless early sensible residence class. The query is, which sensible speaker is the most effective?

It is nonetheless too early for a definitive reply. Amazon’s new flagship Echo speaker launches on Oct. 22, and Apple’s HomePod Mini hits the market on Nov. 16. We’ll get our fingers on all of them to offer you an entire actual world analysis of the area. For now, let’s break down the choices primarily based on what we discovered first hand with the Google Nest Audio, and what we all know to date in regards to the fourth technology Amazon Echo and the Apple HomePod Mini primarily based on the knowledge every firm has made public. 


Apple’s HomePod Mini is the long-awaited little sibling to 2018’s overpriced (however great-sounding) HomePod. Whereas the unique HomePod did not find yourself claiming a lot market share, it proved that Apple, even arriving late to the sensible speaker occasion, may compete with business leaders Google and Amazon.

The HomePod Mini is a way more cheap $99, which is about the identical value as 2020’s Echo and Nest Audio. Like its opponents, the HomePod Mini will home its firm’s voice assistant — Siri, in Apple’s case — and connect with a slew of Apple-specific options, such because the messaging app in your iPhone or the House app controlling your Wi-Fi-connected mild bulbs. As well as, Apple says the HomePod Mini will be capable of alter its audio output to the acoustics of the room (one thing Amazon has additionally claimed in regards to the new Echo), and obtain music “handed off” from iPhones held in its proximity. Plus a number of HomePod Minis will be capable of mechanically play songs in stereo.

With regards to voice help, Siri is less polished than Google Assistant and Alexa, however it may well accomplish all of the fundamentals its opponents can. For a lot of prospects, the selection will come all the way down to model loyalty.

Apple’s different large emphases with the HomePod Mini are safety and privateness: Nothing you say will probably be shared with out your consent; you may select whether or not to ship your recordings to Apple or not; your queries won’t be related along with your Apple ID; and it will not reply to non-public requests until your telephone is within the room. These options largely match what opponents are doing, although we’ll actually be capable of dig into the small print additional when all of the units are on sale.

The HomePod Mini’s clear draw back is its value in relation to its dimension: the Mini’s profile is extra corresponding to Google’s Nest Mini and Amazon’s Echo Dot, each of which price solely $50. The truth is, at a tiny 3.Three inches tall, the HomePod Mini is even shorter than the brand new, 3.5-inch-tall spherical Echo Dot. Whereas we cannot be capable of inform how that impacts its sound efficiency till we assessment the gadget, it is exhausting to think about the HomePod Mini will boast sound efficiency on par with the considerably bigger, $100 units from Google and Amazon.

Learn our first take of the HomePod Mini.

Chris Monroe/PJDM

The $100 Nest Audio is changing 2016’s Google Home, and Google says it’s “75% louder with a 50% stronger bass than the unique [speaker].” That efficiency comes from its 19mm tweeter and 75mm mid woofer, that are each barely smaller than their counterparts within the new Amazon Echo (which additionally has two tweeters). However general, the speaker continues to be about twice the dimensions of the HomePod Mini, and usually talking, larger is healthier relating to audio system. Our reviewer referred to as the Nest Audio “an enchancment in each method” over the Google House.

Google Assistant continues to be essentially the most natural-sounding voice assistant, although Amazon is holding the competitors tight with its current upgrades. For most individuals, whether or not you like Siri, Alexa or Google Assistant will most likely come all the way down to use-cases: Siri integrates with iPhone capabilities, like messaging; Google Assistant works with Google’s Calendar, Gmail and search companies; Alexa works with Amazon purchasing. All three will get the job achieved to various levels for many requests in between.

With regards to sensible residence connections, the Nest Audio brings a stable array of integrations with other Nest devices, together with the big hitters within the linked residence area. That stated, it merely would not have the broad attain Alexa does with sensible residence builders — significantly these with extra area of interest merchandise.

Learn our Nest Audio review.


Amazon’s focus in 2019 was on {hardware}, rolling out half a dozen speakers and displays in a single yr, however in 2020, Alexa is the star. Alexa’s improved home security features, extra naturalistic speech and predictive sensible residence controls may make it much more aggressive with Google’s still-superior Google Assistant. These options rolling out — together with Google’s and Siri’s solutions to them — will proceed to maintain the voice assistant race tight between these three.

The brand new Echo’s {hardware} equally prioritizes residence integration, that includes a Zigbee receiver to attach sensible lightbulbs and an Amazon Sidewalk bridge to attach with the tech large’s rising community of residence and near-home units.

As a speaker, the brand new Echo will seemingly see marginal enhancements over the previous generation, which had stable sound high quality for the $100 price ticket (though it is at the moment obtained a Prime Day low cost value of $95). It options what seems to be the identical 3-inch woofer because the final technology, however provides a second 0.8-inch tweeter, which seemingly means higher distinction in mid- to high-range sound. Amazon additionally says the speaker’s sound will mechanically adapt to the acoustics of the room it is in, very similar to the HomePod Mini’s.

For a $100 price ticket (or $95 for so long as Amazon’s Prime promotion lasts), the brand new Echo is a reasonably candy deal. Read our Amazon Echo 2020 first take.

#HomePod #Mini #Amazon #Echo #Nest #Audio #sensible #speaker


David Priest