Technology

Ghost of Tsushima vs. Sekiro: The ultimate samurai showdown





Large Breath of the Wild energies on this screenshot.


Screenshot by Sean Keane/CNET

I liked Sekiro: Shadows Die Twice. It is a brutally troublesome but masterfully crafted samurai sport from the staff that created my favourite sport ever — Dark Souls. I used to be ready to dislike Ghost of Tsushima out of spite as a result of I believed it could be a dumbed down model of Sekiro meant to please these much less keen to endure the torture of near-impossible boss fights. 

Now that I’ve sunk 30 to 40 hours into Ghost of Tsushima, I am ready to say I like this sport too. It is great in its personal means and never the Sekiro clone I used to be anticipating. Sure, each characteristic fast-paced sword fights, however Ghost is an open world journey the place tense moments of fight are balanced by serene meadows and non-obligatory actions like accumulating flowers and composing haiku. Sekiro, alternatively, is a tightly designed linear expertise the place the main focus is nearly all the time on making it from level A to B in a single piece.

However, each draw heavy inspiration from traditional samurai movies, each have coronary heart pounding one-on-one duels and epic swordplay, and each are set in reimagined areas of historic Japan. I even have related emotions of triumph after I win a tricky struggle in each video games. So regardless of their variations, I am pitting them face to face. 

Fight

sekiro-1

Sekiro’s fight is quick, exact and brilliantly polished.


From Software program/Activision

When Sekiro got here out final yr, it featured the most effective melee fight system of any sport I’ve ever performed. It is quick and brutal. Normally in video games with swords, you chip away on the well being bar of any enemy little by little. That is an accepted online game conference, but it surely would not have the identical urgency of traditional samurai movies the place a single strike might pierce an opponent by way of the center. 

Sekiro provided sword fights that made you are feeling such as you had been combating with a harmful weapon. You are not chipping away at a well being bar, you are sporting down your opponents or maneuvering to interrupt by way of their protection. Once you do, you may strike them useless in a single killing blow. You’ll be able to even beat bosses shortly when you discover ways to break their protection, however the problem comes from their capacity to do the identical to you. 

Ghost of Tsushima returns to a standard well being bar strategy. You’ll be able to break an opponent’s protection, however that merely opens them up to a couple strikes that whittle down their well being. And you do not have a defensive meter your self, to allow them to’t flip the tables in the identical means. Happily, the fight remains to be modern in its personal means. 

On tougher difficulties, opponents assault relentlessly and blend and match their strategy with feints and unblockable assaults. You’ll be able to parry and counter many of those assaults, however you additionally must dodge and make use of the Ghost’s many additional instruments, like utilizing smoke bombs to maintain management of the gang. The combination of assaults retains you on edge, and essentially the most distinctive twist of the system comes within the type of stances. 

ps4 games 2


Now playing:
Watch this:

Best PS4 games to play during quarantine



3:23

Other games, such as Nioh, have used combat stances to allow you to change up your attack pattern to fit the situation. Ghost’s system is simpler and works beautifully as a result. Each of your four stances is tailored to one of four enemy types. All of your attacks are much more effective against a certain enemy if you’re in the proper stance.

I actually prefer Ghost of Tsushima’s combat to Sekiro’s when it comes to dealing with crowds. You need to mix strategy and honed reflexes to stay ahead, and it’s a wonderful feeling to dodge a shield swipe, stab the bearer to death, switch stances and counter the incoming spear thrust, then finish by bringing your blade down to slice off the attacker’s arm. It’s exhilarating and takes practice to get right, then feels rewarding when you do master it and can successfully defeat large crowds without being touched.

Sekiro is a little clunkier when dealing with crowds, but is still fine. You can lock onto one enemy to center your focus, but switching the lock to multiple opponents doesn’t feel graceful. In general, with Sekiro I tried to control crowds so I was only facing one attacker at a time. 

When you go one-on-one with an opponent, Sekiro’s combat is better, and that’s why the boss fights shine. Each one is a puzzle where you need to figure out the right mix of aggression and defense that will effectively break your opponent’s defenses before they take down yours. Opponents have particularly powerful moves that can do devastating damage, but each has a specific counter option so you can turn the tide in your own favor if you read the attack correctly. 

You have extra tools in Sekiro as well, but they’re more of a supplement to a strategy than a means of turning the tide like in Ghost. Ghost, then, is more flexible with combat, but Sekiro finds a lot of tactical wiggle room in a simple system, and bosses constantly keep you guessing until you solve the puzzle and can counter everything they throw at you. 

Ghost of Tsushima’s combat evolves with new moves and tools as you progress, but the bad guys don’t change that much. The one-on-one fights are also great and suspenseful, but they similarly start to blend together as the game progresses. Because Sekiro focuses on those one-on-one duels, each boss encounter is strikingly different from the last and defeating a tough opponent after multitudes of attempts grants a huge feeling of exhilaration that Ghost can’t match. 

As a whole, I still prefer Sekiro’s combat, but Ghost of Tsushima comes closer than I thought it might.

Stealth and exploration

ghost-of-tsushima-20200704213833

Ghost of Tsushima mixes beauty and brutality really well. 


Sucker Punch/Screenshot by Sean Keane/CNET

Outside of combat, the games differ in style, tone and even gameplay. Do you want to ride a horse through sun-swept fields, battle enemy encampments, and learn about a small group of misfit friends over the course of several side missions? Go with Ghost of Tsushima. Do you want to navigate tightly designed levels filled with hidden shortcuts while looking for secrets, searching for the way through and doing everything you can to stay alive? That’s Sekiro. 

Both have simple stealth systems so you can get the drop on enemies — sometimes literally. You can climb in both games and assassinate your opponents from above. The open world of Ghost of Tsushima lends itself to more flexibility, but the levels of Sekiro are crafted well enough to allow for plenty of avenues of approach. Both transition well from stealth to open combat if and when you get spotted. Neither stealth system is as robust as what you’d get in a stealth-focused title such as Metal Gear Solid 5, but both are functional and fun. 

I’ll call this category a tie. Ghost of Tsushima has more flexibility most of the time but also missions with forced stealth that annoyed me. Structurally, it offers the freedom of an open world, but has more bloat in terms of time filling side quests compared to the tight structure of Sekiro. Both are good examples of two different video game genres.

Accessibility and storytelling

Ghost of Tsushima gets extra points for accessibility. After a recent update, it has options that include making subtitles easier to see, helping with aiming projectiles and reducing the speed of enemy attacks. It also has four difficulty settings, and I like the way it ramps up the challenge with each. 

Most games turn enemies into damage sponges on higher settings, so it takes forever to kill them as they absorb blow after blow. Ghost of Tsushima doesn’t change health. You’re just as deadly at higher difficulties, but the enemies are more aggressive, they hit harder and the timing needed to counter enemy moves is stricter. 

sekiro-gamescom01

Sekiro’s boss fights are a treat. 


Activision

Sekiro, infamously, doesn’t have explicit difficulty options. You can find a few hidden items in the game to make combat more challenging, but you can’t make it less punishing. I appreciate this, as it’s perfectly balanced as it is and part of the experience is patiently learning what the game is trying to teach you. You don’t have to be a great gamer to beat Sekiro, you just need to be willing to learn. That said, accessibility options would have been a nice extra touch. 

As for the story, I liked the narrative in Sekiro. Other games by publisher From Software have left most storytelling to background lore, but Sekiro has explicit beats and interesting characters. It veers into some strange territory and still takes some detective work to figure out all of the nuance, but I was generally invested in the fates of the main cast.

The story in Ghost of Tsushima is one of the highlights. It has a compelling villain and interesting, flawed main characters with engrossing story arcs. The story in Sekiro was competent enough to keep me involved. The story in Ghost of Tsushima was potent enough to make me genuinely emotional.

Declaring a winner

I wasn’t expecting this to be a close fight, but I truly think both games are great. Sekiro has better combat, but Ghost of Tsushima comes close, has a better story and is more accessible. And yet Sekiro is more unique. Ghost of Tsushima mixes ideas from other series like Red Dead Redemption and Assassin’s Creed, but the combat stands on its own. 

Red Dead Redemption 2

Ghost of Tsushima surprisingly has a lot in common with Red Dead Redemption 2. 


Rockstar Games

Neither game is perfect. I mentioned Ghost of Tsushima’s bloated side missions, plus the pacing suffers a little in the middle of the game. Sekiro makes you face tedious mini-bosses during the first couple of hours, which isn’t great. Carefully picking off the minions surrounding the boss so you can have a head-to-head faceoff is exciting once, but a giant pain when the mini boss takes several attempts to beat.

Ghost of Tsushima is the better fit for most people looking for a fun samurai game and a way to relax after work. It’s not wholly original, but it’s polished and fun. I still prefer Sekiro for its thrill and unique design. If you want a challenging game that pushes sword fighting to the extreme, Sekiro is better. I also believe that years from now, because of its originality, Sekiro will stick out more in my memory. 

To an extent, Ghost of Tsushima is what I feared it would be — a samurai game for the masses that will likely sell better than Sekiro. Surprisingly, I’m OK with it. It’s a good game in its own right and I’m glad I got to play both. I’m still going to call Sekiro the winner, but the Ghost would make for an amazing boss fight. 





#Ghost #Tsushima #Sekiro #final #samurai #showdown



Author

Andrew Gebhart