Gardyn review: Building a wall of salad is easy with smart hydroponics

I have been residing with a 5-foot-5-inch salad-producing machine in my kitchen since June. This good, indoor vertical hydroponic system, referred to as the Gardyn, grows heaps of recent, natural greens. We’re speaking gourmand salad each day, countless basil and mint, and sufficient dill to make you’re feeling responsible that you do not know any recipes that use dill.

I haven’t got to fuss with watering or ensuring it will get sufficient gentle. No soil, no bugs. Simply a pc assistant named Kelby that pings my cellphone with alerts because it watches over the vegetation. (Sure, it truly watches. With cameras.) The entire automated system begins at $800.

The Gardyn is an indoor, good hydroponic system that grows recent produce fairly rapidly.

Bridget Carey/PJDM

It is designed for people like me who don’t have any out of doors yard, and no spare time to look after vegetation. Throw in a pandemic, and this grew to become the proper alternative for me to check a smart garden. You imply to inform me that I, a Frazzled Working Mother™, can preserve my household consuming freshly picked lettuce, herbs and veggies with no need to go wherever or cope with folks? Convey on the kitchen jungle!

The Gardyn system holds 30 vegetation. Every plant begins as a seed tucked in somewhat pod, referred to as a “yCube,” which snaps into slots alongside three columns. You may consider these particular yCubes as type of like Keurig cups — however for kale as an alternative of espresso. 


Seeds for the Gardyn come inside little pods referred to as yCubes.

Bridget Carey/PJDM

On the base of the construction is a six-gallon tub of water that is two ft lengthy. The entire construction sticks about about 16 inches from the wall. A pump inside brings water up the plastic poles, trickling right down to the plant roots on a schedule. Two gentle poles within the entrance face the vegetation, giving them loads of simulated daylight. The machine simply wants an influence outlet, a house Wi-Fi connection and a cell app to make it work.


The Gardyn can develop 30 vegetation without delay. House owners can select from a wide range of lettuce, herbs, greens and flowers.


A number of sensors handle a lot of the every day care robotically. However this machine will not allow you to set it and neglect it — it nonetheless requires an occasional human contact to maintain it good and orderly, a lesson I discovered the arduous method within the first couple months that I documented in my video evaluation, embedded above.

What’s shocking is how rapidly it produces meals. In 4 weeks I used to be harvesting some fancy dinner salads. By the second month, I had bushes of basil. And in three months, my vegetation certified for “Feed me, Seymour!” jokes. That stated, I misplaced many good sprouts alongside the best way as I obtained the dangle of the machine. Should you’re contemplating getting the Gardyn, or wish to know if it is best for you, I hope my expertise might help by answering the massive questions:

What can I develop?

The Gardyn system affords greater than 20 totally different forms of produce, all natural, non-GMO and grown within the US. The Gardyn additionally sells six flower varieties. Should you’re feeling adventurous, you may develop no matter you need utilizing seedless yCube pods and tuck your personal seeds inside. (I’ve carried out it, it really works.)

This hydroponic system is not made for root greens (reminiscent of carrots, beets and onions), however you may attempt something that grows above floor. And if it will get too large, pop it out and switch the pod to soil. I transferred one to a pot with no drawback.


A cherry tomato I grew in my Gardyn. I preserve my tower largely stocked with lettuce varieties, together with cilantro, basil and mint.

Bridget Carey/PJDM

Fruits at the moment accessible are cherry tomatoes, jalapeños and candy peppers (strawberries coming quickly). Obtainable herbs are basil, chives, cilantro, dill, Mexican tarragon, mint, oregano, Italian parsley, rosemary, sage, Thai basil and thyme. As for greens, it goes method past the store-bought iceberg. You may get arugula, breen, butterhead, cardinale, inexperienced mustard, Matilda, kale, pink mustard, rouge d’hiver, swiss chard, tatsoi and watercress.

The starter pack contains a mixture of salad greens and herbs. After you can order whichever seed pods you need despatched within the mail. Pay for every a la carte, or subscribe to a service to get a month-to-month provide.


The system enables you to pull vegetation out and in at any time, so you may rearrange or trim the roots when wanted.

Bridget Carey/PJDM

What’s the associated fee?

The Gardyn gadget and starter package collectively are $799, or funds of $37 a month, and for now they’re solely accessible within the US. The starter package comes with greater than 30 numerous yCube pods, together with a bag of plant meals (powered minerals and vitamins) that will get combined within the water tank. 

As with most tech lately, there is a subscription service to think about. A Gardyn subscription mails 10 new yCubes to you each month. You simply decide the vegetation you wish to develop. After three months these unique starter pack vegetation will seemingly must be changed, so if you do not get a subscription, you may want to purchase extra refill pods by yourself.

Decide to a membership for a yr of yCube deliveries, and it will value $408 — that is roughly 120 vegetation. Should you purchased the identical quantity a la carte, that may come out to about $600.

Commit to 2 years and it comes out to lower than $three a plant, a price of $686.

It will be very tough to vogue your personal plastic yCube alternative pods — to not point out the trouble of trying to find comparable distinctive natural seeds — so shopping for these seed pods direct from Gardyn is the one reasonable possibility. 

Clients can arrange cost in month-to-month installments. So a starter-pack Gardyn gadget with two-year subscription is $69 a month, or $1,485 all up front.


The roots of your vegetation drink up the water collected in these reusable cylinders. The middle yCube pod pops out to be replanted in soil or thrown away, if that point has come.

Bridget Carey/PJDM

Is the subscription price it?

It is a number of inexperienced for greens. However you may really feel cheated when you overpay and go a la carte. You wish to preserve the Gardyn stocked with recent produce, sure? You are planning on preserving this round for a number of years, sure? Then you definitely’ll use the membership, so it is price it.

Here is what is not very clear whenever you get began: You will want to begin rising new vegetation every month to eat properly. You possibly can’t simply preserve the identical starter-pack vegetation alive perpetually. 

I discovered that 10 new vegetation a month was reasonable, particularly at first. Some rookie errors led to me tossing a number of sprouts out. And you’ll want to plan for vegetation to solely be good for consuming for about three months. (I attempted to maintain my favorites alive for so long as attainable, however with age some vegetation start to flower and the leaves have a tendency to alter in style. Harvesting time would not final perpetually.) If you wish to preserve the meals provide steady, you may wish to arrange a cycle of getting new vegetation each month.


When you see one among these suckers rising out of your lettuce, it is time to say goodbye. It is now attempting to make flowers as an alternative of meals, and that may change the style of leaves. This occurred to me within the third month.

Bridget Carey/PJDM

To start with you want the convenience of the subscription service, as a result of you haven’t any concept what you are doing and you may wish to experiment with totally different vegetation. While you discover your rhythm and discover the vegetation you’re keen on, then possibly you may solely must develop six seeds in a month as an alternative of 10. However that is no drawback, since you’ll simply have a backup provide of seeds for the subsequent spherical. Extra meals for later when the plan ends.

What’s up with these cameras?


Here is what the cameras see, as captured from the Gardyn app.

Bridget Carey/PJDM

There are two stationary cameras on the sunshine posts, pointed on the vegetation, taking nonetheless photographs each 30 minutes. The Gardyn workforce says no audio or video is captured. Customers can open the app to get a view of the final photograph taken — useful if you wish to verify on vegetation whenever you’re away from the home for an prolonged time. (I feel folks used to name that trip.)

The thought is that, when you want some customer support assist, a human can see current photographs of your vegetation for reference. And the Kelby good assistant can use the cameras to detect some fundamental elements of plant well being. From the combo of alerts I obtained, it is arduous to all the time inform if the recommendation is from a pc or particular person. I have been alerted to verify on wilting vegetation or to trim them when an excessive amount of progress lined the cameras, and obtained a pep discuss when some herbs did not develop. 

The cameras will be deactivated in settings.

Is it actually all automated? How a lot work is required?

The essential every day stuff is automated. Water and light-weight are set on a schedule within the app, you do not have to mess with it. When water is operating low, you may get alerts to refill the tank. 

However there is a bit more work concerned than I initially anticipated. It is not a magical do-it-all machine. The “good” assistant would not inform you every little thing. Nevertheless it’s additionally fairly easy work.

The most important chore comes as soon as each month whenever you’ll must spend 10 minutes cleansing the tank and refreshing the water. You will should raise the complete plant tower construction up and off the water tank. I discover it somewhat awkward to raise however I can do it alone. 


To scrub the tank, you’ll want to raise and take away the highest of the Gardyn.

Bridget Carey/PJDM

While you get yCube seed pods within the mail each month, it takes somewhat TLC to get them going. You possibly can’t simply pop them within the Gardyn tower. You must sprout them in a separate container. Add somewhat water and wait a few week for them to sprout earlier than snapping them into the Gardyn. Why the wait? Your established Gardyn has a water tank combined with plant meals. Little seeds cannot develop properly in the event that they’re doused in water crammed with mineral salts.

Twice per week you need to inspect the vegetation to reap leaves, be sure the vegetation aren’t blocking one another’s gentle (you may transfer a plant into one other slot at any time), trim roots and ensure issues are trying clear.

You will must be on prime of something that appears off, and message customer support for recommendation if wanted. Once more, do not anticipate Kelby the good assistant to chime in with all the recommendation. (See beneath.)


Generally the roots get aggressive and begin to develop down into the pipes. This butterhead lettuce is due for a root trim.

Bridget Carey/PJDM

How good is the assistant, Kelby?

Not as good as I hoped. It is fairly useful with the fundamentals the primary couple of weeks, however truthfully, I want I might have switched its persona to being extra pushy and direct after I had no concept what was happening. 

I believed Kelby would ship alerts for each single facet, reminiscent of telling me how a lot to reap (no), or if one thing is able to harvest (not fairly), or that it might say one thing concerning the sketchy algae I noticed rising on the base (nope), or how lengthy I ought to anticipate vegetation to final (nada) or that if I do not harvest sufficient I could hurt the plant (mistaken once more).


Inexperienced algae progress was a bit a lot on this cilantro plant pod. Gardyn assist informed me to cowl the bottom with aluminum foil, and it helped.

Bridget Carey/PJDM

My first two months had some snags. A number of vegetation grew gross mould and fungus within the middle as a result of I did not harvest sufficient and so they grew to become bunched up too tightly. Algae grew on the base of some others. (Preserve one thing moist for weeks and feed it mineral salts and, uh, life finds a method.) Once I introduced this up in an interview with the CEO, he stated most homeowners electronic mail buyer assist as quickly as they’ve any questions. Guess I ought to have carried out that sooner. 

And as soon as my vegetation obtained too large and obstructed the digital camera’s view, I did not get a lot recommendation about something. To be truthful, the Kelby system is consistently adjusting its recommendation as it’s a new product. And if one thing goes mistaken with a plant and recommendation cannot clear up it, the corporate affords to ship a alternative. 

Now that I am a number of months in, I discovered what’s truly far more useful than Kelby is the Facebook group for Gardyn owners. I did not uncover its existence till the top of my evaluation. However the community has members posting all types of questions and suggestions, and members get actually fast solutions from Gardyn employees. It is also filled with fascinating hacks and problem-solving methods.

The Gardyn app does provide a useful resource of tips about tips on how to look after every plant, like a digital plant guide. However I’d like to see extra photographs or movies to assist. Like, the place precisely do you chop whenever you harvest chives? How a lot ought to I trim the roots? I guessed some issues and Googled others. Lots of residing with a Gardyn at first is studying by doing.

I needed a wise system to only inform me every little thing robotically. I’ve two younger children, plus attempting to prepare dinner and clear and preserve a job — I do not wish to learn up on and examine tips on how to look after vegetation. I do not need extra homework. However after trial and error, my fourth month of possession appears rather more easy and I do not want as many suggestions.

How is that this with children? Is it protected?

You probably have a child or toddler, you ought to be cautious the place you place this in your house. You do not need a younger child climbing on it or grabbing the lights, which might get highly regarded. 

My son is a yr previous — a major trouble-making age — and there is been no drawback with him round our Gardyn. He truly is somewhat candy with it, copying us by attempting to tug off leaves to eat. However I can not let him be with it unattended. I preserve it within the kitchen, and I can block off entry with a gate. 

I even have a 4-year-old daughter who bumps into it nearly each day. Nevertheless it handles the occasional knock. 

A facet perk is that the Gardyn obtained her keen on consuming healthily. Within the morning my daughter feedback on little modifications, like how the tomatoes are altering colour. She will get to select her salad at dinner, or pluck the basil for the pasta. It makes being wholesome enjoyable.

Can meeting be carried out by one particular person?

Sure, however hooking within the lights takes persistence and a cautious hand. It took me about an hour. The poles and water tanks are product of a tricky plastic, with items that lock collectively and will be taken aside. 

How a lot meals does it produce?

Herbs or veggies can take some time to mature. However when you’re rising a tower full of massive, leafy greens, you may simply have a facet salad a number of nights per week, if not each night time. That stunned me. The cherry tomatoes I have been rising are taking longer to mature — so my tomato vegetation are extra of an occasional deal with than a continuing supply of meals.  

I am now rising extra lettuce than herbs, and we’re having the tastiest salads I’ve ever had in my life. I might most likely win friends with this salad

What are you able to management with the app?

The system is programmed to deal with water and light-weight scheduling for you. However the app does provide guide controls. You possibly can even dim the brightness or flip it off fully if you need it darkish within the room for film night time. There’s additionally a button on the Gardyn base that turns off the lights. 

The best way it is designed, all vegetation get the identical quantity of water and light-weight without delay, which works out high-quality. So it would not matter the place you place your vegetation on the columns.

The app is how you may order extra yCubes and get upkeep alerts from Kelby. Nevertheless it lacks a strategy to rapidly message the customer support workforce with questions. I would love a strategy to begin a chat with somebody proper from contained in the app.

What did you study that you simply want you’d identified from the beginning? 

Some vegetation might solely actually final three months earlier than it’s a must to toss ’em. So whenever you order new vegetation, attempt to preserve a provide of your favourite ones in order that when one plant meets its finish, a brand new sprout has already been in progress to take its place. 

Additionally, I want I had harvested extra usually at first. I used to be fearful that if I ate an excessive amount of I would kill the plant, however as an alternative I did not eat sufficient and there was waste.


Now that I perceive the system higher, I’ve vegetation in numerous life levels to maintain the meals provide steady. This child inexperienced is simply two weeks previous.

Bridget Carey/PJDM

Is there anything like this on the market?

There are a lot of forms of indoor gardening methods popping up. The iHarvest could possibly be the Gardyn’s closest competitor, additionally holding 30 vegetation and beginning at $800. It additionally has a pump system to automate watering. A special strategy is the Rise Gardens modular shelving system, which has an app to assist monitor vegetation’ wants. 

Many are a lot smaller (and cheaper) and designed to sit down on a desk prime, just like the Click & Grow Smart Garden 3 and the AeroGarden.

Would you get it, understanding every little thing you already know now?

If I simply noticed this marketed on-line, I’d not be satisfied to drop $800 on it, plus all the prices of extra seed pods. I’ve gotten by simply high-quality in life with store-bought baggage of salad. However after this evaluation expertise, my husband and I each do not wish to return to a life with out rising our meals. It feels empowering to all the time have recent produce inside attain. And the Gardyn makes it straightforward. I want straightforward proper now.

The Gardyn is sort of a piece of furnishings, however furnishings that grows tomatoes and will get children maintaining a healthy diet meals. With on a regular basis we spend at residence, it is good to have greenery to look after in the home. It is a peaceable second after I verify on the vegetation. In that sense, you may say it feeds the soul.

#Gardyn #evaluation #Constructing #wall #salad #straightforward #good #hydroponics


Bridget Carey