For those who’re new to grilling or simply in search of an improve out of your outdated mannequin, the abundance of grills in the marketplace could make picking the best one really feel overwhelming. It is laborious to know whether or not to go for a fuel grill (fueled by propane or pure fuel), kamado grillcharcoal grillpellet grill or even perhaps a portable model

Fuel grills are an excellent place to start out for brand spanking new grillers and make an excellent improve, too. They’re easy to make use of, straightforward to regulate and roomy sufficient to feed the entire household. We put six of the best-selling fashions you can buy right now by way of their paces on the CNET Smart Home that will help you discover one of the best fuel grill. After cooking up 12 racks of ribs, 18 complete chickens and 96 burgers, this is the way it all shook out.

Notice our authentic listing included the DynaGlo 4-burner (DGE486GSP-D) and Dyna-Glo Sensible House Dwelling 3-burner (DGB390SNP-D) amongst our prime picks. These fashions at the moment are discontinued, and we have up to date our suggestions accordingly. 

Learn extra: The best outdoor tech of 2020

Chris Monroe/CNET

If burgers are the mainstay of your cookouts and yard barbecues, this Weber fuel grill is a superb alternative. Actually, it is an excellent alternative for cooking throughout. Weber’s 10-year guarantee applies to all its grill components, so you may be set for years to come back, even with heavy use (like, if you happen to let no weekend go by with out having an opportunity to char-broil some burgers). Its constant efficiency in our testing delivered burgers with a great char and a barely pink heart.

The Spirit II E-210 can also be one among Weber’s iGrill compatible models, an extra accent line that features Bluetooth temperature probes you may monitor by way of a companion app. For those who’ll be making ready dishes that require extra time on the grill, the iGrill system will enable you keep watch over issues from a distance.

At $379, this fuel grill sits in the midst of the affordability spectrum. The cons are you that you simply will not get a facet burner or a cupboard to cover your propane tank, although there’s a rack to hold it on with a sliding gauge mechanism. Nonetheless, I used to be happy with the searing and even cooking throughout this Weber mannequin, and I might suggest it to anybody who desires of the proper Saturday spent grilling. 

Chris Monroe/CNET

The identify says all of it. This $499 fuel grill is an efficient alternative if you happen to’re in search of giant capability, and it appears like working in knowledgeable out of doors kitchen. Geared up with 4 burners, two separate fireboxes and a facet burner, this grill will simply conquer cooking for the biggest crowds.

The Char-Broil Business Double Header does a superb job of stopping flare-ups, irrespective of how greasy your meat. And it takes a low-and-slow strategy to cooking, which implies you may chill out in a garden chair with out worrying about whether or not your meat will burn. Nonetheless, it’s costly. You would possibly luck out with summer season gross sales, however be ready to spend huge for an enormous fuel grill that may serve up patties by the dozen. 

Read our Char-Broil Commercial Double Header review.

Chris Monroe/CNET

Weber’s bigger Spirit II mannequin contains three burners. It additionally comes with a propane tank scale and 6 hooks for simple instrument group. It performs properly and offers you the choice of an iGrill accent, a $100 Bluetooth temperature probe that connects to your cell Weber app to watch the temperature of your meals.

Priced larger at $479, the Spirit II E-310 appears nice, presents smarts and is an efficient measurement for most individuals. If the tank scale and iGrill Three accent matter to you, the Spirit II may be price your cash. 

Different fuel grills we have examined

The CNET Sensible Residence editors have been cooking and serving up grill knowledge for a number of years now. Along with the fashions above, listed below are the opposite fuel grills we have examined. These do embrace some fashions which might be at present unavailable. 

  • Char-Broil Signature Series 4-burner: This well-built and sensible Char-Broil mannequin was center of the street in our testing and is priced excessive at $600 (although we did see it for $500 at Academy Sports activities). It comes with loads of cooking house, a facet burner and cupboard doorways. For those who’re a fan of Char-Broil’s grills, this mannequin is a protected wager, however there are higher grills from different manufacturers in your cash.
  • KitchenAid 720-0891C: KitchenAid’s color and style choices are spectacular, however the efficiency of this two-burner fuel grill was underwhelming in all three assessments. For those who’re in search of a two-burner grill, the Weber Spirit II E-210 is a more sensible choice.
  • Dyna-Glo 4-burner (DGE486GSP-D) (not accessible): This mannequin carried out properly in our rib style assessments, outscoring Weber, Char-Broil and KitchenAid fashions each time. Along with 40,000 BTUs throughout the primary burners, there’s additionally a 12,000-BTU facet burner, good for heating up sauces or facet dishes.
  • Dyna-Glo Smart Space Living 3-burner (DGB390SNP-D) (not accessible): Dyna-Glo proved itself as soon as once more when it got here to low and gradual cooking. The Sensible House Dwelling three-burner was the winner of our rib style assessments each time. Hen on this Dyna-Glo mannequin was common in cooking time, however was price it for the crispy pores and skin and tender meat. 
  • Broil King Baron S520 (not accessible): The Baron S520 tended to run sizzling in our testing, and we discovered ourselves burning meals too usually whereas cooking. You will not get any extras both, like facet burners or temperature probes, and it seems to be unavailable on Broil King’s web site.
  • Royal Gourmet (GG3201) (not accessible): We appreciated the grill for the stability of its $200 worth and first rate efficiency. Different Royal Gourmand fashions could also be price contemplating if you happen to’re on a finances. 
  • Char-Broil Performance XL (not accessible): The $299 Efficiency XL was our prime decide final 12 months given its nice efficiency and cheap value, however this five-burner mannequin (#463243518) is not accessible from Char-Broil’s web site or Lowe’s, although the oldsters at Char-Broil inform me there’s a nearly identical model changing it.

How we take a look at

To find out one of the best fuel grill and get a really feel for the way these grills carry out in quite a lot of cooking situations, we carry out three assessments. Based mostly on completely different meats, strategies and warmth settings, these assessments present us how effectively and evenly a grill does (or would not) prepare dinner.


Our first take a look at is ribs. It is an anecdotal spherical, so there is not a linked thermometer set or software program capturing particular knowledge. We preheat every grill on excessive for 10 minutes earlier than turning it all the way down to low, oblique warmth. Relying on the grill measurement, meaning turning one or two burners off fully.

We take away the outer membrane on a rack of St. Louis model brief ribs and season it with an all-purpose rub we use for ribs and rooster. Then, the ribs are positioned on a chunk of aluminum foil and grilled for 3 hours with the lid closed all the time. 


Rib testing takes three hours on low, oblique warmth.

Chris Monroe/CNET

Rib fanatics could not agree with this comparatively brief and smoke-free cooking methodology, nevertheless it permits us to see simply how properly a daily propane fuel grill can prepare dinner low and gradual. Even with the arguably slim three-hour prepare dinner time, ribs on the finish of this take a look at may be tender and juicy.

A blind style take a look at by 5 selfless and devoted (positively not simply there for the free meals) coworkers leads to a ranked listing with the bottom scoring grill declared the winner. We repeated this take a look at twice, you realize, for science.


To check the grill with a midrange prepare dinner time and medium warmth settings, we grill an entire rooster. We preheat the grill on excessive for 10 minutes, then flip the warmth all the way down to medium and switch off burners to create an oblique warmth setting.

As soon as we have trimmed and seasoned the fowl, we place it in a roasting pan and insert one temperature probe into every rooster breast, for a complete of two probes per rooster (this is a vital step — even when the grill has a inbuilt thermometer — as a result of undercooked rooster isn’t any good for anybody). To maintain our outcomes as honest as presumably, all of the chickens are as shut as doable to five.5 kilos.


Complete chickens are cooked on oblique, medium warmth till each breasts attain 165 levels. 

Chris Monroe/CNET

These temperature probes are linked to a datalogger and laptop computer with a software program program that data the interior temperature of every rooster breast each two seconds. Every rooster cooks till the temperature in each breasts reaches a food-safe 165 levels Fahrenheit.

Hen grilled properly ought to have a crispy pores and skin and meat that’s cooked by way of totally however not dry. This take a look at is carried out in three rounds, giving us a strong common cooking time for every grill.


Burgers are our closing take a look at for our grill opinions. We measure out 5.Three ounces of 80/20 floor beef and press them into uniform patties. These patties go right into a grill basket and we insert a temperature probe into the middle of every patty at a 45-degree angle.

With the grill preheated for 10 minutes on excessive, the basket goes onto the grill. After six minutes of cooking, we flip the basket and monitor inner temperature. As soon as the final burger within the basket reaches 145 levels, the batch is completed. A superb burger on this take a look at is one which has each a pleasant outdoors char and a barely pink heart.


Burgers go on the grill over direct, excessive warmth. 

Brian Bennett/CNET

Burger testing factors out any sizzling spots throughout the grill’s cooking floor if one burger constantly reaches 145 earlier than the others in each spherical.

A median 15- or 20-degree distinction throughout the quickest and slowest patties in a batch was the norm in our testing. Crimson flags are raised once we start to see variations within the 30- to 40-degree vary. On this group of grills, solely the Royal Gourmand gave us an actual sizzling spot challenge throughout the grates.

A more in-depth have a look at specs

Evaluating these fuel grills is not all apples to apples. With completely different grill sizes, cooking grates and BTU ranges, a distinction in efficiency is predicted in every particular person out of doors fuel grill. Nonetheless, there are some observations to be made.

One factor our take a look at knowledge highlights is how shortly a grill can prepare dinner by itself medium or excessive setting. That does not imply every grill is ready to the identical preheated temperature. It merely means we turned the knobs to what every grill indicated was medium warmth.

The chart beneath compares every grill’s common cooking time for rooster and burgers over three similar assessments.

Common cooking instances

Char-Broil Business Double Header Char-Broil Signature Sequence 4-burner KitchenAid 720-0891C Royal Gourmand GG3201 Weber Spirit II E-210 Weber Spirit II E-310
Hen 94 min. 75 min. 103 min. 73 min. 117 min. 80 min.
Burgers 14 min., 2 sec. 14 min., 54 sec. 15 min., Four sec. 9 min., 35 sec. 13 min., 26 sec. 15 min., 44 sec.

If pace is not your deciding issue, do not worry. There are different traits you may examine to decide on the grill that is best for you.

Precisely which one is that? It relies on your cooking model. For those who’re cooking for giant teams continuously, you may want a grill with a big main cooking floor, a warming rack and a facet burner. A few of you may also have sturdy emotions in regards to the cooking grates — you want chrome steel, or forged iron grates, or porcelain coated grates, and even porcelain coated forged iron. Look rigorously at every description to make sure you get what you are in search of.  For those who simply plan to make use of your grill for flipping a number of burgers often, stick to a smaller or cheaper mannequin. And naturally, if you happen to’re in search of a portable grill or an indoor grill, these will not be best for you.

On the lookout for a small propane fuel grill with a compact cooking space that will get the job achieved? KitchenAid’s measurement and daring colour choices make it a strong, trendy alternative that additionally cooks meals properly. In order for you that facet burner and loads of energy to go along with it, the Char-Broil Business Double Header delivers nice energy and a trendy chrome steel look. In any other case, I will level you again to my prime decide this 12 months: the Weber Spirit II E-210.

As soon as you’ve got picked out one of the best grill for you, remember equipment. You will wish to have a look at grill covers and decide up grilling instruments like a grill brush, a thermometer to examine for food-safe temperatures and liners for the drip tray.

Check out this chart to match measurement, energy, guarantee and extra.

Fuel grills in contrast

Char-Broil Business Double Header Char-Broil Signature Sequence 4-burner KitchenAid 720-0891C Royal Gourmand GG3201 Weber Spirit II E-210 Weber Spirit II E-310
Value $749 $600 $279 $200 $349 $449
Dimensions (HxWxD) inches 47.8×66.3×23.5 46.2×55.2×27.5 44.69×48.03×21.46 44.9×48.8×22.4 44.5×48.0x27.0 44.5×52.0x27.0
Weight (lbs.) 215 143 72 89.3 103 114
Essential burner BTUs 36,000 30,000 26,000 36,000 26,500 30,000
Aspect burner Sure Sure No Sure No no
Guarantee Burner: 10 years Firebox: Three years Different: 1 12 months Burner: 10 years Firebox: Three years Different: 1 12 months Burner: 10 years Firebox: Three years Different: 1 12 months 1 12 months 10 years 10 years
Major cooking house (sq. in.) 650 530 332 413 360 424

grill testing 10

Now playing:
Watch this:

Testing gas grills at the CNET Smart Home


More grilling goodness

#fuel #grills


Molly Price